First Memory

My first memory of my dad is when he told me he hated me. I was however tall four year olds are, standing stubborn in front of his overstuffed grey chair where he would have his dinner served to him by my mom on the giant cutting board. The board was big enough to stretch from arm to arm, a table on his lap. After dinner, she would cart off the board and he would stretch his black socked feet out in front of him onto the matching ottoman. He and my mom would watch tv from their perches—his the chair and her’s the corner of the sofa near the end table where the lamp would shine on her crossword puzzles and dimestore thrillers. Sometimes I would curl up next to her, straining my eyes at the book while she absentmindedly alternated between patting my legs and erasing incorrect answers.

My sister Karen had told on me. She was five years old, much taller, and slimmer than my short sturdiness. She looked to me like how Snow White was described in the Old Grimm’s Fairy Tales—white skin, black hair, green eyes. I knew even at four that she had been the tiniest baby, and I had been the biggest baby. In her baby pictures, she was dressed in yellow and had a bright smile as she gazed at the camera, holding a block in her slim little hands. My baby picture had garnered me the nickname “Sumo”. I was chubby all over, knuckles mere dimples swallowed by my fat hand that held my oversized head with its dripping cheeks up off the floor. Anyone looking at that picture could tell that baby didn’t coo, she grunted and snorted. I tried to convince myself I looked like Rose Red, Snow White’s baby sister. Rose Red had blonde hair and blue eyes and was shorter. If I didn’t have freckles, if I weren’t so….sturdy, maybe I could be in a fairy tale, too. Rose Red. Even when I was a little kid, I knew I would be the fat best friend, not the star.

Karen had told our dad that I hit her. I probably had, and she had more than likely deserved it. Always so bossy. We were the little ones at home after the big girls had left, one by one. There was a brief bit of time where we all overlapped. The big girls in the one room, Karen and I in bunkbeds in the other. After Becky died and the twins moved out, Karen moved into the big girls’ room. My mom painted it yellow and bought matching curtains and a bedspread. My room was fully pink, from walls to linens as well. I loved my pink room, but missed the sound of my sister when she slept. Sometimes, when she was feeling lovey and I hadn’t been too ornery, Karen would let me sleep in her bed with her. She tucked into the space near the wall, and I would cram right up next to her. Karen always fell asleep before me, mouth open and spit solidifying in the corners of her mouth, loudly breathing. I would put my face up to hers and listen to her breath, inhale the night smells from her mouth.

We fought and loved like puppies. As I grew older, I became the tattle tale, sharing when Karen would do terrible things like ignore me or not give me something I wanted or poke me with her fingers. I would run to my dad and tell him how awful she was. Then I would run to the garage to hide, sad and scared I had told on my sister, and wondering how she could ever handle the terrible punishment that dad must be doling out. My dad would come out to the garage where I had squeezed between the black car and the wall, crying, and ask what was wrong. “Karen’s not sooooo bad!” “No, Karen’s not bad. Come inside, have some cookies.”

This was before that though, when Karen was still more of a tattler than I. I had been called to answer for my four year old crime in front of my dad’s chair. “Come here,” he said sternly, pointing to the floor just to the left corner of his chair, “come here.” I hated that phrase growing up. Nothing good was going to happen when you got there. I stood in front of him, being sternly spoken to for my crime. “Unjust!” my brain screamed. It wasn’t fair. Karen had started it all, and I was in trouble because she spoke up first. I tried to argue, but he wouldn’t listen. My mouth turned down and my brow furrowed, I spoke my terrible instantaneous truth, “I HATE you.”

“Well, good. I hate you, too”

Tears came up behind my eyes as I stared at him. He HATED me??? HE HATED ME??? “You can go to your room.” Then he turned back to the golf on tv.

I went to my room and ignored Karen’s taunts from her own. I lay down on my bed. My dad hated me.

I had always been kind of scared of him, and that continued throughout my childhood. I would be happiest when he would be out of the house at night, refereeing basketball games. He was so tall and it seemed like he would call you to the spot in front of the chair for pretty much any reason. I was more comfortable around my quiet mom who loved books like I did. She would read me stories until I had them so memorized I would convince her I could read them myself. She started thinking I was super smart when I would recite Little Bunny Follows His Nose at the age of three. My mom was where I went when my dad was angry. My mom heard my little secrets and misdemeanors, tearfully confessed on her shoulder or against her arm where I would snuggle while she did her puzzles. My mom paid me no mind as I would act out fanciful pretend stories based on the old school fairy tales she read me, then I would read myself. The ones where little girls danced in shoes that had been heated so thoroughly in the fire they glowed red, the ones where the wolf swallowed everyone only to have his stomach cut open by the woodsman, the ones where one-eyed and three-eyed princesses tortured their two-eyed step sister.

Yet, I also wanted to be with him. My dad would take me swimming, take me running, try to teach me golf. He wanted me to be athletic and smart and strong. Instead I was dreamy and fat. Still smart, though. He could play well sometimes. I would pretend to be a nurse and take his blood. Then, not knowing what one does with blood once one takes it out with a giant syringe, I would pretend to squirt it into a glass to have him drink it back. You need to have plenty of blood. Then my dad would turn to me after finishing his glass of blood, eyes gleaming, “Ohhhhh that blood is gooooooooood. I’m a vampire now!” And he would come running after me, chasing me around the living room. I had turned my dad into a vampire and had to figure out how to make him just a dad! The only answer was another shot, carefully administered by poking my right index finger through a v made with my left hand. His eyes would then soften and he would stop trying to grab me, and would let me lead him back to his chair so he could rest up from having been a vampire.

I look like my dad’s side of the family. When I go to see my cousin’s from my mom’s side, they see me, “Oh, you’re your dad’s girl!” I hated looking like my dad when I was little. He was scary, and a boy. As I grew older, I still hated looking like my dad. Too masculine, too sturdy. I also continued to be slightly afraid of him. I would watch sitcoms where the dad gave the daughter some wise advice and a hug. My own dad would practice putting in front of his chair and talk about the golf game with my mom. I would ask if he would do things with me and he would be puzzled, “You can golf with me anytime you want.” I didn’t want to golf. That’s all my parents did.

As I grew older, not golfing became a part of my identity. I refused the game my dad loved, that my sisters played well. I was a decent golfer, probably could have been good. But dad yelled even more when playing golf than he did normally. It seemed a poor option to continue. I also didn’t date much in high school. I didn’t feel valued by my dad and didn’t see how anyone else could value me, either. I could have sought validation from guys my own age. Instead, I decided there was no way they would like me. When I was 23 after having left and come back and left and come back to live in my parents’ house a few times since I was 18, my dad asked me when I would find a man to take care of me. “I can take care of myself.” He was unconvinced.

I ended up moving far away from home, first to Reno, then Colorado (then back home), then Alaska, then Japan (then back home), then Alaska, New Orleans, Mongolia, Southern Oregon, Korea, then to DC to start a proper career of international development. My first post overseas in my new role was in the Philippines. I was to be there for two years, then go to a nice four year post, continue my growth in my chosen work in international development with a health focus. I was as far away from home as I could get. Far away from the family I had grown apart from over the years. Hoping that I had found my chosen home.

How do you solve a problem like…

At my father’s funeral, my sister went through all of the sisters and explained our relationships with our dad.

Through her tears, pictures flashed behind her on the church wall as she described the events in the photos. Golfing, children, dancing at holidays. Mine was me, alone, in a bright orange fuzzy jacket. By the jacket I could tell it was a photo I had sent to my parents from Mongolia. No photos with me and my dad. Nothing more recent than a time when I lived in a country far away five years ago. The absent daughter, the prodigal daughter. Oh wait, the prodigal son returned. A prodigal daughter would have come back.

I saw that picture, me alone laughing while swathed in bright orange and unfortunate bangs, and wondered if I had made the right choices. My sister then called out my adventurous spirit, so like my dad’s. Mentioned the pride my dad had had in me, his youngest, his least settled, most fat, least stable, most … distant.

I had never thought of my dad as proud of me, as seeing value in my driving need to go far from home and see something other. What rang in my ears more than the idea of pride this man had had in me was that he had asked me, when I was 23, when I would find a man to take care of me. Me, who had moved to Reno when I was 19, had figured out how to go to university, had graduated from said university in another state at 25. When would I find a man to take care of me? To guide me, mold me, make sure I was okay as I flittered and floated around the world.

I told him I never would. That I didn’t want someone to take care of me, that I, if anything, just wanted someone to love me. That was enough. Or maybe too much. Taking care of something or someone doesn’t necessarily imply partnership or love or anything other than duty and commitment. I wanted both more and less. Someone to be my equal, my partner, to allow me to take care of him as I took care of myself and as he took care of me. I wanted to work and explore and go out into …. wherever out was.

We were too alike, my dad and I. Noses sharp and dominant, a propensity to talk to salespeople, to waitresses and waiters, to know people somehow someway in the towns we went to. We were stubborn and assured at all times of how very right we were. Right we are. Our eyes are the same color. Our windows to the world. We agreed on the style of cars but not the cost. Oh the cost of things. I was his own propensity to frivolity taken to its logical and financially challenging extreme. He worried that his littlest, his shortest, his youngest, his most freckled would be unable to contain herself as she aged, unable to maintain a moderate and modest income. Interested in too many things, beholden to none, the irresponsibility of the youngest imprinted on her.

Proud of me? How could he be proud of someone so not what he wanted from a child? Not obedient, not fiscally conservative, not socially conservative, not fit. not not not. And yet, I believe my sister’s words. I was and am the facet of my dad that is fiercely independent, talkative, interested in beauty and style, loving. I am the downfalls in his personality–taken to whims and quick changes of temper and the ever present belief that I AM RIGHT. I am right. I am the smartest person in the room, even when I’m not.

I miss my dad. It has been almost 6 years since he died and I don’t know how many years since he was taken from us. The taking was slow and measured until it wasn’t. My distance which was my savior is my unknown regret.

As a 40 year old, I can only wish things are different. What else do you wish in middle age? I wish my dad were still alive. I wish I were more wholly myself when he was alive. I wish we could have had a real beer, a true beer together. I wish we could have talked openly about … I don’t know. Something. About his wishes for himself. His wishes for his kids. What he gave up as he had 7 kids.  I wish I hadn’t left home so very young. I wish I had found patience earlier, patience with myself and with others. With my parents.

My dad died when I was in Afghanistan. I’m not sure when a good time would be for him to have died. I’m not sure when a good time would have been for me to be in Afghanistan. I am sure now that these were not two times that should have dovetailed. My dad became sick as I was coming into my own as a expat. I’m not sure it was the best that these all happened at the same time. Had I to do it over, I don’t know what I would have changed, but I would have changed something.

I would have had a relationship with my dad that allowed for a photo of the two of us together. Not a photo of me smiling while the two of us were a world apart.